Both players have been integral to the KKR since joining the team, and the defending champions would ideally prefer to have them both in their squad in IPL 2025. However, it seems like only one will continue in Kolkata, with ESPNcricinfo's Nagraj Gollapudi revealing that Shreyas Iyer's future might be influenced by interest from other franchises offering him substantial contracts. Now that KKR will need to envision a future without their skipper, the franchise will assess his value in comparison with Rinku. If the choice falls between these two batters, the balance tilts in favour of the latter.

Let's analyse why KKR are better off retaining Rinku Singh than going all out on Shreyas Iyer. Why Rinku Singh Has an Edge Over Shreyas Iyer? Ever since his breakthrough for the KKR, Rinku Singh's form in recent IPL seasons has been promising. Although he scored only 168 runs in IPL 2024, his numbers in 2023 were stellar with 474 runs at an average of 59.25 and a strike rate of 149.53. A capable finisher who reminds fans of MS Dhoni, Rinku hitting five sixes in IPL 2023 is one of the most iconic moments in the league's history. In contrast, Shreyas Iyer scored a respectable 351 runs in IPL 2024. While the numbers themselves aren't terrible, it is a drop-off from his numbers in his first season for KKR, where he scored 401 runs. The fact that the skipper missed the entirety of IPL 2023 due to back surgery will be a cautionary tale for the Knight Riders hierarchy.

For KKR, Rinku offers a younger, more versatile option for the batting lineup. His ability to strike at almost 150 suggests he can seamlessly anchor and finish innings, often with impressive results even under pressure. Retaining him for the 14-crore slot would be cost-effective, while releasing Iyer could free up 18 crores in the budget, allowing KKR to strengthen other areas, especially by potentially re-signing Sunil Narine, whose all-round ability remains pivotal to KKR's balance. What is KKR's Advantage of Retaining Rinku Singh? Rinku's connection with KKR's fanbase has also blossomed, particularly since his match-winning finishes. His loyalty to the team and his rise from the domestic circuit have made him a relatable figure for fans, something Iyer, as a high-profile, centrally contracted Indian player, has not fully matched.

Rinku's ascension from the grassroots aligns with KKR's philosophy of backing emerging talent, offering them a player with high potential at a relatively lower price tag. While Shreyas Iyer undoubtedly brings experience, KKR needs to weigh this against his inconsistency and the opportunity cost of his 18-crore salary. Additionally, his significant injury history raises concerns about his long-term availability, especially with franchises increasingly looking for durable, fit players for high-intensity roles.