A fresh debate has gripped cricket fans over which Royal Challengers Bengaluru batting line-up was more fearsome — the iconic 2016 side or the explosive 2025 version.

The discussion gained momentum after experts on a cricket show compared the legendary trio of Chris Gayle, AB de Villiers and Virat Kohli with the modern power unit of Rajat Patidar, Kohli, Phil Salt and Tim David.

Why 2016 still feels legendary

The 2016 RCB side is remembered as one of the most destructive batting teams in IPL history.

That season, RCB reached the final and became known for chasing huge totals and dominating powerplays. For many fans, the aura of that team remains unmatched.

Why 2025 looks more complete

The 2025 batting group, however, is seen by many as deeper and more balanced. With Patidar’s calm strokeplay, Salt’s explosive starts, Kohli’s experience and David’s finishing power, the side offers threats across every phase of an innings.

Unlike 2016, where much depended on the top three, the newer line-up is considered more versatile and adaptable to modern T20 demands.

Experts split, fans divided

Former cricketers and analysts remain divided. Some believe no trio can surpass Gayle, AB and Kohli at their peak. Others argue the 2025 unit is more dangerous because bowlers get no relief from top to lower order.

The emotional answer vs tactical answer

Emotionally, many fans still choose 2016 for nostalgia and star power.

For Bengaluru supporters, both eras represent unforgettable chapters in the franchise’s journey.

For Bengaluru supporters, both eras represent unforgettable chapters in the franchise’s journey.